Why Worry About Mold?
We have a lot to learn about mold and its impact on our indoor environments. While we may not fully understand the degree of hazard mold presents, we do know this: mold has become a serious concern for building occupants. Mold-related litigation happens, and case results and appellate decisions seem to be increasingly favoring plaintiffs. These are realities that every building owner, engineer, and contractor must face.
Proper insulation practices are the building owner’s best defense against mold infestation in chilled water, refrigeration, and HVAC systems. Materials that are non-absorbent, fiber-free, and easy-to-clean are the best choice for avoiding mold and its far-reaching consequences. Closed-cell elastomeric foam provides these properties for longer lasting systems and greater owner peace of mind.
Protecting Ductwork and Cold Water Piping From Mold
There are more than 100,000 known species of mold. Mold spores (seeds) are everywhere, indoors and outdoors, in our building materials, on our clothes, and in the air we breathe. We can’t avoid them, but we can minimize their potential for growth in our buildings. And we should. Mold is a common allergen; it exacerbates asthma and can cause infectious disease in some people. It also can have far reaching legal consequences for owners and others in the construction industry.
The Nature of Mold
Mold requires three things to grow: (1) food, (2) temperatures between 40 to 100 degrees F, and (3) moisture. Virtually any organic material will serve as food (including dust) and our indoor temperatures are well within the acceptable range. Therefore the best bet for controlling mold is to carefully control the moisture in our buildings. This involves much more than wiping up the occasional leak. It requires vigilant control of moisture entering into the building and preventing condensation throughout ductwork and cold-water piping.
Moisture Happens
Mold doesn’t require standing water to grow. High humidity is moisture enough for mold spores to germinate. Ideally, buildings should maintain relative humidity of 60% or lower—not only for comfort, but to prevent mold growth. Unfortunately, areas of high humidity are bound to occur in some areas of an HVAC system.
High relative-humidity levels in air-handling units occur any time outdoor air dew points are above the cooling coil discharge temperature (typically 61°F). Air discharged from the cooling coils under these conditions usually has a relative humidity level of 90% or higher. Provided food is present, this is all it takes for mold to grow.
Condensation is another problem, occurring whenever air comes into contact with surfaces that are cooler than the dew point of the surrounding air. This makes cold-water piping and cold ductwork prime areas for unwanted moisture. This moisture can condense into liquid, wetting such building components as ceiling tiles, drywall, carpeting, or open-cell insulation, thus setting the stage for mold growth.
Insulation: The Key to Preventing Unwanted Moisture
Insulation is the best way to avoid condensation in ductwork and piping systems. However, if improperly installed or damaged, some types of insulation can provide a cozy breeding ground for mold.
Closed-cell elastomeric foam is the only type of insulation that provides thermal efficiency along with the necessary prevention of condensation and water-vapor transmission on cold-water and air-handling systems.
Studies show elastomeric foam insulation is better for mold prevention because:
- Fiberglass structure provides a wicking opportunity for moisture; therefore moisture can quickly travel, expanding the area for potential mold growth.
- Fiberglass tends to trap and collect dirt. In fact, the air pockets that make fibrous-type materials an effective insulator also makes them prone to trap and retain dirt.
According to the April 2004 ASHRAE Journal, “Porous materials such as internal fibrous glass liner have been identified as a major source of fungal contamination.”
The same article references a study in which fungal growth on fiberglass linings was found in 92% of 150 office buildings in Minnesota with IAQ problems.
This particular study found that the average microbial levels in fibrous glass insulation are hundreds—and in some cases thousands—of times higher than the microbial levels found on closed-cell foam insulation under the very same environmental conditions.1
Based on these facts, many experts recommend replacing fibrous glass liners with closed-cell foam insulation materials that are less likely to encourage fungal growth in areas where humidity is likely to exceed 70%.
An increasing number of schools, universities, and other facilities seeking better IAQ have made the same decision, replacing existing insulation with elastomeric foam, not only for its mold-resistant properties, but also its fiber-free, dust-free, and non-particulating construction.
Why Closed-Cell Foam Is the Better Choice for Mold Prevention
Unlike fiber-based products, which have been found to hold moisture for up to 16 days2, closed-cell elastomeric foam won’t absorb moisture. Its smooth surface also inhibits the accumulation of dirt that serves as a food source for mold.
Properly installed and maintained, elastomeric foam is an extremely effective deterrent to biological contamination. Even if closed-cell foam duct liner gets dirty or wet, its smooth surface makes it extremely easy to clean. The same cannot be said of fiber-based duct liners, which are notoriously difficult to clean and deteriorate more quickly under adverse conditions. While many fiberglass duct liners are encapsulated with a protective jacket that acts as a vapor retarder, this outer covering is easily punctured. Closed-cell elastomeric foam requires no such vapor retarder or protection.
Finally, when fiberglass insulation gets wet, the North American Insulation Manufacturers Association (NAIMA) recommends that it be removed and thrown out as soon as possible to prevent mold and fungi growth.
10 Steps to Prevent Moisture in Piping and Ductwork
Moisture needn’t be a problem in a well-designed and maintained HVAC system. The following preventative measures will help eliminate moisture problems and minimize the risk of mold growth.
- Fully insulate all cold-water pipes and fittings and condensate drain pipes with closed-cell elastomeric foam material
- Avoid gaps or unsealed seams, and be sure to insulate all fittings, valve stems, etc.
- Whenever possible, use insulation materials that have non-moisture-absorbing properties – especially on chilled-water and refrigeration piping where condensation can become a problem.
- Fully insulate cold-air supply ducts and air-handling equipment.
- Specify and install adequate insulation thickness to control condensation. Condensation control typically requires greater insulation thickness than thermal efficiency.
- Carefully monitor indoor relative humidity, keeping RH at 60% or below.
- Design systems with adequate drainage in mind. This means installing equipment at appropriate pitch for proper drainage, as well as providing for easy access to drain pans so that workers will be more inclined to check for drainage more often.
- Change filters regularly and inspect for any accumulation of moisture or mold.
- Clean and inspect air handlers annually and clean ducts every five to ten years. In certain climates and environments, cleaning may be required more often.
- Seal cooling ducts during the heating season to prevent moisture from accumulating. Dampers are not airtight and therefore should be sealed by taping plastic sheeting over them. ▪
1: MICROBIAL LEVELS ON INTERIOR SURFACES OF VENTILATION DUCTWORK, CLOSED CELL FOAM VS. FIBROUS GLASS INSULATION AND GALVANIZED METAL. P. Ellringer, S. Hendrickson, Tamarack Environmental Inc., St. Paul, MN; C. Yang, P&K Microbiology Services, Inc., Cherry Hill, NJ
2: (Samimi BS. The environmental evaluation: Commercial and home. Occupational Medicine: State of the Art Reviews. 1995;10(1):95-118.
Note: Armacell closed-cell, elastomeric foam meets important testing criteria for fungal and bacterial resistance, including UL181 for mold growth, ASTM G21/C 1338 for fungi resistance, and ASTM G22 for bacterial resistance.
